The goal is to allow the clavicle to heal while gradually regaining a functional shoulder.

A clavicle fracture corresponds to a rupture of this bone located between the sternum and the shoulder. Depending on its location, the number of fragments and their displacement, it can be treated with a sling and a gradual resumption of movement, or require surgical intervention.

The decision depends on the clinical examination and imaging, but also on the discomfort, associated injuries, activity level, and the person's expectations. A displaced fracture does not automatically mean that surgery is necessary.

UNDERSTANDING A CLAVICLE FRACTURE

Fracture de la clavicule : patiente s’habillant avec précaution après une blessure à l’épaule.

WHEN CAN A TRANSACTION BE DISCUSSED?

Most isolated clavicle fractures can be treated without surgery. However, surgery may be considered after assessment of the fracture, the skin, surrounding structures, and the individual's needs.

 

  • Significant displacement or loss of contact : the fragments are clearly separated or shortened. The situation must be assessed on a case-by-case basis.
  • Open fracture or exposed skin : the bone or fragments endanger the skin, or a wound communicates with the fracture.
  • Unstable or complex fracture Multiple fragments or a fracture of the outer end can make stability more difficult to achieve.
  • Insufficient consolidation : a lack of consolidation or persistent discomfort may lead to discussion of a secondary intervention.

 

A minimally displaced, stable fracture with no threat to the skin can often be managed without surgery. The choice of treatment depends on pain and function, imaging, age, activity level, available treatments, and the patient's goals.

ASSESS THE FRACTURE AND ASSOCIATED INJURIES

The first assessment aims to define the fracture and to verify that it is not accompanied by damage to the shoulder, thorax, nerves or vessels.

Clinical examination

The doctor examines the pain, swelling, skin, and position of the shoulder. He also checks the sensation and circulation in the arm and hand.

Imaging

An X-ray usually allows the fracture to be located and the displacement to be assessed. Further examinations may be requested if the fracture is complex or if an associated injury is suspected. The diagnosis is based primarily on clinical examination and X-rays.

Quick assessment if needed

A wound, very tight skin over the bone, a cold or numb arm, new weakness or difficulty breathing requires urgent medical evaluation.

Examen clinique d'une fracture de la clavicule

WHAT FIXING TECHNIQUE CAN BE USED?

The choice depends primarily on the location of the fracture, the displacement, its configuration, and the quality of the bone. Not all fractures require the same equipment.

The technique is chosen according to the fracture and the patient; no single method is suitable for all situations.

A plate is fixed to the clavicle to hold the fragments in place. This method allows for the stabilization of various fracture configurations. The placement of the hardware and any discomfort it may cause are discussed before the procedure.

In some middle third fractures, a device can be placed in the bone canal. This option is not suitable for all fractures and depends on their shape and stability.

 

Fractures near the shoulder may require a specific fixation strategy, depending on the stability and associated ligamentous structures.

If the fracture does not heal as expected, surgery may be considered. The procedure may include refixation and, depending on the case, a bone graft.

 

NON-SURGICAL TREATMENT

When the fracture is stable and the skin is not at risk, treatment often involves a sling, temporary adjustments to activities, and a gradual return to movement. The duration of immobilization and the pace of rehabilitation are adjusted according to pain levels and medical check-ups.

 

  • Scarf It supports the arm for comfort during the initial period. It is generally preferred to a figure-eight bandage for most acute fractures.
  • Pain relief Medications should be taken according to the advice of the healthcare professional treating the patient. Treatment should not be started, stopped, or changed without medical advice.
  • Progressive mobility Elbow, wrist, and hand movements are often encouraged. Shoulder movements are resumed according to progress and team instructions.
  • Controls Clinical and, if necessary, radiographic monitoring allows for the evaluation of the fracture's position and its consolidation.

 

fracture-de-la-clavicule-indications.webp Fracture de la clavicule : évaluation de la mobilité de l’épaule en consultation.

EVOLUTION, LIMITATIONS AND POSSIBLE COMPLICATIONS

The treatment is chosen after discussion of the expected benefits, limitations and risks specific to each option.

Objectives and expected results

The treatment aims to allow the clavicle to heal and the arm to regain full use. Most isolated fractures heal well without surgery, but the outcome depends on the type of fracture and its progression.

Boundaries

Consolidation takes time. A lump or difference in contour may persist, even when function is satisfactory. Pain, stiffness, or discomfort on exertion may also last beyond the initial period.

 

Risks and complications

A fracture may heal with residual displacement or fail to heal completely. After surgery, possible complications include infection, wound healing problems, hardware irritation, nerve or vascular damage, or the need for further surgery. Their likelihood depends on the individual situation.

RECOVERING AFTER A CLAVICLE FRACTURE

After a fracture treated without surgery or with fixation, pain and discomfort gradually change. Instructions vary depending on the stability of the fracture and the chosen treatment.

 

Initially, the sling can help support the arm and reduce discomfort. Hand, wrist, and elbow movements are generally maintained according to the instructions received.

 

Shoulder mobility gradually returns. Physiotherapy may be recommended to regain range of motion, strength, and control of movement when the fracture healing process allows.

 

Returning to work, driving, and daily tasks depends on pain level, mobility, the affected side, and the demands of the activity. Activities that pose a risk of falling or impact should be postponed until after medical advice has been given.


Sports activities are resumed gradually after assessment of consolidation and sufficient functional recovery. Contact sports and activities with a risk of falls require particular caution.

 

The progression must follow the evolution of the fracture and be validated by the medical team.

Fracture de la clavicule : exercice progressif de mobilité de l’épaule en physiothérapie.
Fracture de la clavicule : échange entre une patiente et un professionnel de santé sur sa prise en charge.

A CARE APPROACH TAILORED TO EACH PATIENT

Two people with a fracture that appears similar on an X-ray may have different needs. Displacement, stability, skin condition, associated injuries, and the progression of pain are all factors in the assessment.

 

Dr. Benoît Coulin takes into account age, anatomy, bone quality, activity level, occupation, previous treatments, and personal goals. The indication for surgery and the choice of fixation are discussed based on all of these factors.

 

The monitoring is adapted to consolidation and functional recovery, with a progression of movements and activities determined according to progress.

«"Treatment is decided based on the fracture, its progression, and the specific needs of each patient."»

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

No. Many isolated fractures are treated without surgery, especially when they are stable and the skin is not at risk. The decision depends on the location, displacement, associated injuries, and the patient's overall condition.
The duration varies depending on the pain, the stability of the fracture, and medical instructions. The sling is primarily used for support and comfort initially; its use is adjusted as the recovery progresses.
Resuming shoulder movement depends on the type of fracture, its stability, and the level of pain. The doctor or physiotherapist will advise on when to begin and how to gradually increase the range of motion.
Yes, a bump or a change in contour may remain visible after healing. This does not necessarily mean that the shoulder will not function properly; pain and function are also taken into account during follow-up.
The recovery time varies depending on the fracture, age, health status, and treatment. Functional recovery can continue after bone healing; medical follow-up allows for monitoring this progress.
It depends on the pain, the affected side, mobility, the type of activity, and the ability to drive safely. Returning to work should be discussed with a doctor, especially for physical labor or driving while wearing a sling.
Resumption of activity is gradual, following pain relief, regained mobility, and assessment of bone healing. Contact sports or sports with a risk of falling require medical clearance before resuming activity.
Not systematically. Removal can be discussed if the hardware is bothersome or depending on the situation, after assessment of consolidation and the benefits and risks of a new intervention.

Does a broken clavicle require surgery?

A clinical examination and imaging analysis will help assess the fracture, its stability, and the treatment options best suited to your situation.